Faith Pennybaker


Faith Pennybaker

Faith Pennybaker

Phone: M: 813.956.8701 813.956.8701 mobile
Phone: O: 941.907-1033 941.907-1033 office
Office: Coldwell Banker Residential Real Estate
8334 Market Street
Lakewood Ranch, FL 34202-9410



Meet Faith Pennybaker

It's a tremendous pleasure helping clients fulfill their dreams. Since joining one of the world's largest and most trusted brands, Coldwell Banker Residential Realty, Faith has had the opportunity to work at many levels in a local real estate boutique as well as a global network of real estate professionals. She applies cutting edge marketing techniques for residential real estate in Bradenton, Sarasota, Parrish, Ellenton, Palmetto, Anna Maria Island and Lakewood Ranch.

Faith holds 25 years of industry experience making her highly sought after, and she has distinguished herself as an elite Real Estate Agent in Manatee and Sarasota County. Faith delivers a higher standard of service, from her background in New Home construction and specialized financing, to her superior negotiating skills which she obtained while earning her CNE Certified Negotiation Expert Designation which is held by only Thirteen percent of Agents across the nation.

Faith's consistent benchmark for professionalism, expertise and integrity is demonstrated with her proven track record of successful sales in Parrish, Ellenton, Palmetto, and Bradenton real estate, earning her a consistent spot in the top Ten percent for sales year after year.

Faith and her team are excited to show you what EXCEPTIONAL service and results look like. Make sure to visit our PREFERRED PARTNERS page for additional service options!


Meet Additional Team Members

Amber Weimann

Amber joined the Pennybaker team as a realtor in January 2018. With over fifteen years in customer service, meeting and helping people is her passion. She is a hardworking and dedicated mother of two beautiful girls. Having renovated and flipped homes in the past, the real estate world was the natural choice for her career. She has been in the Sarasota/Bradenton area for almost ten years now after relocating here from Wisconsin. She is committed to her clients and won't stop working until she finds them the home of their dreams. She knows that buying or selling your home is a personal and important time in a person's life, and wants to make the process as easy and enjoyable for her clients. In the fast paced world of technology that we live in, Amber understands the importance of keeping up with the changing world of Real Estate marketing.

Sarah McNeely

Sarah is excited to be joining the team as an administrative assistant and has moved to the area February of 2017 and also lived in Sebring, FL for a year. Sarah originally hails from Ohio. What brought Sarah to Florida was family. Sarah enjoys spending time with her husband, step-kids, volunteering at her church and what sunny Florida has to offer. Sarah has worked in the customer service industry for over 15 years, worked as a Pastoral Secretary at Grace Bible Church in Sebring. Sarah worked for a previous real estate office before joining the Pennybaker team and is excited to work with the team doing the contracts, marketing, being a key player for the team.



Find Your Next Home
You need someone who knows this area inside and out! We can work with you to find the right home at the right price for you, including all the neighborhood amenities that matter - not to mention the essential criteria you have for your ideal home


Sell a Home
When it's time to move, you need someone who will advertise your home, show to prospective buyers, negotiate the purchase contract, arrange financing, oversee the inspections, handle all necessary paperwork and supervise the closing. I can take care of everything you need, from start to close.

Consult on Home Selling Tactics
Oftentimes buyers don't visualize living in your home the way you do. I can make your home attractive to its ideal audience - which can help you get top dollar. Things like staging the home, making repairs or minor improvements, or even simply painting the walls can be the difference between a home resting on the market and one that's sold fast.





 Click to preview your Visual TestimonialClick to preview your Visual Testimonial

"When my husband and I decided to relocate back home to Florida and purchase a home I reached out to my bestfriend who had just recently purchased a home and she referred us to her realtor Faith Pennybaker. Faith was very curtious, polite, and very knowledgeable about the housing market. We were a little hesitant about purchasing a brand new home because of wanting to downsize on the mortgage payment from our previous home but Faith made us feel at ease and in the end got us exactly what we wanted and more. I would recommended Faith Pennybaker to anyone looking to purchase their new home."

  -Trinity Pelayo, Client

"Faith has been a huge asset to the real estate business. She works with pride, honesty, and integrity! I would recommend Faith hands down as a fantastic agent who really cares about her clients' wants and needs. She makes every effort to meet and exceed all expectations."

  -Cathy Kaufman, Client

"When it comes to integrity, Faith stands tall. She will go the extra mile to see that your home shopping/buying experience is professional and comfortable and that you REALLY do get the home of your dreams. I highly recommend Faith whether you are buying/selling or simply shopping. You will not be disappointed!"

  -Guyann Bracken-Fay, Client

"Faith helped us purchase a home in Watson Glen. She was a professional and made us feel at ease. She kept our best interest at the center of our experience. She was never to busy to help us and keep us informed of anything pertaining to our purchase. We appreciated working with Faith. She was a valued asset to the company and to us."

  -Nancy Gifford, Client

"I have known Faith Pennybaker for the past 2 years. She worked for the company that sold the home that my Dad and I live in now. She was the first person I came in contact with and after explaining our needs she knew exactly the home we needed. She invited me to come out and look at the home and I was blown away by what I saw. She worked with us tirelessly step by step until our closing. She was excited and encouraging all along the way which kept us excited. Each day that I wake up and step out of my room into another area of the house, I'm still at awe knowing that this is my home. I'm very grateful for Faith's knowledge and expertise of how she handle our situation. I have already recommended her to my friends and will continue to do so in the future. I have several aspirations that I want to venture into and I'm hoping that Faith would be my agent every step of the way. Thank you!"

  -Nan Tolbert, Client

"It is with great pleasure that I provide this endorsement on behalf Faith Pennybaker. Faith was my home consultant for the home I had built in Riverview in 2009. Faith is very professional, sincere, and genuine and treated me as more than just a customer. She was very responsive to all of my home related questions and consistently went above and beyond to ensure I had the information that I needed. I would without a doubt recommend to anyone I know, friends and colleagues in the Tampa Bay area looking to purchase a home to Faith."

  -George Graham, Client

"Faith was very prompt and honest with us. She gave us her professional opinion and it worked. Faith sold our house in one day. She was prepared and ready when the house went on the market."

  -Sugarbear76453, Client

"Faith was very professional all through the process, she is personable and very easy to communicate with. I was very impressed with Faith's high tech marketing skills. Faith kept me informed of every showing and the feedback she received. Faith really knows the business."

  -P Biehle, Client

"Faith is a great realtor to hire. She was able to help us sell our home after one day on the market. She is very knowledgeable in the area of real estate and was more than happy to answer all of our questions and help us have a smooth sale."

  -Anonymous Seller, Client

"Faith was very well versed on the mathematical process of figuring the price of our new home. And she gave us tips and suggestions on how to negotiate the best deal for us. She is very personable and puts you at ease right away. I would highly recommend Faith as a real estate agent!"

  -Tina Clark, Client

"Faith helped us throughout our entire home buying process from start to finish. This was our first home, and we were also building from scratch. We felt very confident and well prepared for the entire process thanks to Faith. Her awesome personality and overall knowledge is hard to beat. She continues to keep in touch and make sure we are completely satisfied even 2+ yrs later. You definitely won't regret working with her. Thanks Faith!"

  -Christian Mcgowan, Client

"Faith Penny Baker helped us to buy a home from 1,400 miles away. We met with her in person and she took us around to visit numerous homes. She found a community that fits our needs perfectly and helped us to build our dream home. I found out after we moved in that other people who didn't work with a realtor had a ton of issues with their homes, and we did not because Faith Pennybaker was on top of the whole process with us. She is attentive, professional, puts her clients needs first, and is the best real estate agent anyone could hope for. I highly recommend her. We had a wonderful experience and if I ever have to sell this house, I will work with her again."

  -Chi Kulig, Client

Recent Sales

Featured picture for the property A4176648
Featured picture for the property A4176411
Featured picture for the property A4166578
Featured picture for the property A4172347